|
As the date
of departure neared, I didn't want to leave Florida sunshine
for babushkas wearing aprons, disheveled old men, pet bears
meandering through the streets, Siberian freezes prohibiting
movement beyond a sorry approximation of a dimly lit hotel
room, and vodka and communist drab everywhere. I was prepared
to coat the few square inches of skin exposed outside my parka
and ski mask with some kind of whale blubber emulsion for
protection from the arctic chill. Duty called, and I mindlessly
made my way to the airport, not wanting to consider the twenty-hours
of travel and what lay beyond. I expected the worst, but
I was in for a surprise.
My
prejudices shattered like glass. The week and a half I spent
in Poland went far too quickly. As part of the American Embassy's
Black History Month cultural outreach program, I was scheduled
to lecture around the country about The Highwaymen,
a group of African-American landscape painters. In between
presentations, the Embassy's cultural affairs office arranged
meetings for me with university educators and museum curators,
while introducing me to Polish cultural life, from flea markets
to restored palaces, and to the finest restaurants, which
they treated as everyday fare.
The
little downtime that my itinerary permitted was used to walk.
That's what I like doing best, be it in India, Haiti, or Brazil.
Just me and my Leica finding our way as we wander aimlessly,
to soak up the place. I'd long wanted to see Eastern Europe
personally. When I finished graduate school, I chose to return
home to Miami Beach to spend a decade documenting the inevitable
demise of the old world community which elderly Jewish men
and women had established there for themselves. They created
a rich lifestyle that was referred to as "the last resort."
Many of these people had numbers tattooed on their forearms
and most had stories to tell, often referring to Eastern Europe.
Finally arriving, Poland intrigued me instantly.
First
the Nazis, and the communists after them, made sure that barely
traces remain of Warsaw's Jewish ghetto. Adjacent to a resident's
apartment garden between the drab concrete high-rise apartment
buildings that characterize the communists' workers' paradise,
a section of the wall that once bounded the ghetto remains.
A small plaque, and stones left by the regular stream of visitors
to this unlikely corner of Europe distinguish this otherwise
ordinary wall from the many standing around it. Modern monuments
stand in tribute to the Ghetto Uprising heroes and the Umschlagplatz,
the point of departure to the Treblinka death camp from the
northern ghetto wall. Maybe these are enough. They stand symbolically
in a strange kind of inverse proportion to the atrocity. There
was little sense of Judaic history, not unlike the
lack of attention paid to the now-gone old world Jews who
had characterized my home, Miami Beach. Perhaps I should not
have expected anything more. But I did because I've long felt
that the presence of the South Beach Jews, a trek that began
in Eastern Europe, was slighted there in favor of the relatively
vacuous pop culture that today receives so much disproportionate
attention.
I
was moved by everything in Poland, and more often than not,
profoundly. I admit to being under the sway of the charm and
diligence of the Embassy's Cultural Affairs Specialist Izabella
Szarek. Iza remembers the communist days soberly, but with
an appropriate sense of disdain and ridicule. Today she is
much more focused on the renaissance of art and culture in
Warsaw and beyond.
Especially
moving were the audiences responses to my slide-lectures.
They weren't reacting to me, but to the Highwaymen story itself:
how, with the odds stacked squarely against them, these disenfranchised
young Blacks nonetheless realized the American dream, and
in the process left the visual legacy of modern Florida, the
Sunshine State, as the place to realize their hopes and aspirations.
The phenomenon of the Highwaymen is as much a lesson in sociology
than in art. It is a story of transcendence that typifies
the best of American values.
The
reactions of the six audiences to which I presented were terrific.
Young Poles were quick to recognize the significance of the
human achievement, and the way American society hindered it
(the reality of racial discrimination) at the same time that
it facilitated it (the myth of boundless opportunity). They
grasped the social / cultural milieu and considered issues
of the artwork. The college students as well as museum audiences
were notably attentive and inquisitive. From aspiring visual
artists to professors of the social sciences and their students,
questions were many and meaningful. Most enthusiastic was
noted scholar Prof. Bonena Chylinska, the director of Ethnic
Studies at Warsaw University, who has spent time in the US,
researching Black culture. She and her standing-room-only
classes of students remained well into their lunch hour asking
me questions.
From
the university, Prof. Chylinska, Iza, and I drove through
Warsaw to the riverside Boathouse Restaurant for lunch. Sans
the snow, it could have been in Malibu. I was beginning to
realize that Poland, Warsaw at least, is cosmopolitan, but
I was just on the verge of recognizing how far the country
had come during the past fifteen years since shedding its
communist past. I look outside during a lull in our in conversation
and take in the snow-covered landscape. People are out and
about despite the cold. There, and as we drive to Fabryka
Trzciny, our next stop, the surrounding beauty hits me.
Oddly,
despite the temperatures that would be painfully frigid by
Florida standards I wasn't uncomfortable then, or during the
subsequent days of the trip. I'm cold at home when the mercury
drops to 65-degrees outdoors. Little by little I recognized
how the excitement of discovery of something new and fascinating
and beautiful wards off even the harsh weather.
I
am also taken by how beautiful every young woman is. Even
clad in layers of clothes, each one looks like a runway model.
It is another indicator of how far the days of communism are
behind them here. Stylish clothes that would have been completely
unavailable fifteen years ago, and would have attracted the
decidedly negative attention of communist authorities, are
now the norm. This impression amazes me throughout the trip.
In
profound contrast, we next visited the old industrial side
of town, known as Praga. The buildings' walls, pock-marked
by bullet holes, and the occasional bricked-in starburst pattern
of an exploding artillery shell are living reminders of the
ferocity of the Soviet-Nazi battle for Praga sixty years ago.
It is today becoming Warsaw's Soho. Space is affordable if
not in pristine condition or surroundings, yet the area is
rapidly gentrifying. Inside, the spaces might as well be in
Manhattan. Once "a desolate and ruined factory,"
the Fabryka Trzciny now houses the avant-garde Klementyna
Bochenska gallery along with theaters and clubs that are among
the trendiest in Poland. At Bochenska we viewed an exhibition
by Lodz Kaliska. These post-conceptual artists use "staged
photography" from pastiche versions of famous paintings
by Polish masters to recent photographs critiquing and parodying
modern art as they explore the possibilities of new media
and readdress media advertisements. At the intimate Nizio
Gallery nearby, photographs of elderly women seductively dressed
like ballerinas appear haunting and striking in their life-sized
glares.
That
evening, at Atelier Foksal, I was to share my own photography,
images mostly of America. Teresa Starzec and Andrzej Bielawski
opened Atelier Foksal in 1991. The painters and teachers strove
to establish an open environment for those searching for new
forms of expression and wishing to develop their talents,
regardless of age or station: "We do not require any
previous experience; we offer you all necessary materials,
high quality teaching methods, and a pleasant atmosphere for
your artistic explorations." Again, I was impressed by
the interest of the students and teachers, and their warmth,
which, although warned that Poles are not demonstrative especially
with their emotions, I was sensing was a staple among them.
An
embassy car picked me up in the morning at the Europejski
Hotel, where I had been staying since arriving and which I
was now used to. Patrick Lahey, the Embassy's Cultural Attach
assumed that I'd prefer one of Warsaw's historic hotels rather
than one of the modern chain hotels that are popping up all
over town. Photos in the hotel lobby show that it was little
more than a pile of rubble in 1945. It is now a strange image
of 19th century elegance, Stalinist trappings, and ornate
failed attempts to emerge from them in the post-communist
age. Patrick knows a little something of my tastes in travel.
He and I first met in Haiti in 1989 when he was working at
our Embassy there, and I was on my second Fulbright fellowship,
photographing all over that atrophying country.
Patrick's
about the most intrepid traveler there is, an Indiana Jones,
of sorts. We hooked up in Port-au-Prince to charge to uncharted
places that most of the world would classify as completely
inaccessible. When we drove deep into the bush, well past
any semblance of anything that resembled a road, Patrick would
nonchalantly pull a machete from behind the truck's seat and
begin whacking away the tangles Patrick's seen more than anyone,
I suspect, of Haiti during these modern times, and he was
motivated by a love of the people and culture (not to mention
by his spirit of adventure). He's fallen for Poland too, and
a Polish woman, his wife Beata, with whom he has a beautiful
family.
It's
a far cry from when we slept in places that cost about a dollar
a night, often with spiders and lizards crawling across the
walls and mosquitoes dive-bombing throughout the night. There
was no glass in those windows, and the bathroom facilities
were stale and dark closets at the end of the hall where hot
water was a foreign myth. In fact, this trip to Poland was
luxurious and serendipitous; over the years we had lost track
of each other (although he was never far from my thoughts),
and Patrick was looking for me through google to ask me a
photography-related question. What he found was pages and
pages about my book, The Highwaymen, on the web. He saw an
opportunity knocking, as he realized the story would be prime
material for the Embassy's outreach during Black History Month.
Iza
next escorted Patrick and me to Lodz, once a capital of the
textile industry, where wealthy factory owners built palaces
for themselves in front of barracks-style workers' residences
like barons overseeing their land. Technically, Patrick is
Iza's boss, but they refer to each other as colleagues, and
as I watched Iza walk Patrick through his official duties
as attaché it wasn't clear who was who's boss. Anyone
who watched them in action would quickly conclude that they
were best of friends thoroughly enjoying the mutual adventure
of working together. Although in great company and a fine
company car, I loose myself watching the surroundings whiz
by villages, farms, snow-covered landscapes; a certain frustration
about temporalness grabs me, so I begin photographing life
passing by through the car window-frost and all.
Curators
of the Lodz Cinematography Museum took us for a tour of their
facilities. The palace converted into a museum featured ornate
staterooms where the original owners entertained the cream
of Lodz society, and, still functioning, Poland's first elevator.
But it included such exhibits as room after room of a miniature
puppeteers diorama, and props from recent well-known movies.
The setting elevated even the tools of the trade and publicity
posters to high art. A poster that Steven Spielberg signed
when he was in Poland to film Schindler's List was
cast among scores signed by other film notables who had visited
the facility.
At
the "American Corner" the Embassy's satellite cultural
office in Lodz, my presentation of the Highwaymen was an intimate
gathering, and as always this Cinderella tale was well received.
Afterwards Patrick, Iza, and I met Jaroslaw Nowak, the Director
of Promotions for the City of Lodz for lunch at Piotrkowska
Klub. I was encountering taken-for-granted elegance and old-world
civility everyday and everywhere in Poland, and it took particular
hold of me here. After the usual cycle of abandonment and
renovation, the club's pre-war elegance was more parodied
than restored, but it was a pointed example of what the past
can always expect the future to make of it. Like many Poles,
Jarek had had the opportunity to spend several years in the
US. He was equally at home in Lodz or New York, and in both
places had developed a fascination for Judaica that was leading
him to look for an opportunity to spend a few years in Israel.
Time
and time again, the environment impressed me. The cold was
pervasive, but it never bothered me. And this from a photographer
who prefers to work in shorts and T-shirts, in tropical settings.
It was rather odd to me that I was always comfortable. I am
convinced that it was more than proper clothing, that it somehow
had to do with simple pleasantry and sheer beauty of the people
and places that I encountered wherever I went. Snow fell intermittently,
occasionally allowing for a few hours of blue skies. In Poland
in February, the sun is always low on the horizon even at
its zenith. But to my own surprise and immediate delight,
I loved photographing in the dull light, enlivened by the
vivacity of the place and people.
After
lunch I dragged Iza to the streets so I could photograph (she
wouldn't let me go alone, actually). It was so cold that she
had to stop to buy a knitted cap. But I remained unfazed,
taken by the discovery of place. Patrick, meantime, had to
work. The Embassy was sponsoring the opening of the American
Friendship: Herbert Hoover and Poland exhibition at Lodz
History Museum in the Poznanski Palace. It's the story of
another of those fascinating but little-known connections
between the US and Poland. When World War I ended for the
US in November of 1918, the Poles had to continue fighting
for two more years to secure their independence from the emerging
Soviet Union. American volunteers fought along with the Poles
against the communists, and Herbert Hoover headed up the world's
largest ever famine relief program to save Polish citizenry
from starvation after the ravages of years of warfare. Although
I stayed politely for Patrick's opening remarks, I slipped
out afterwards to walk the snowy streets of Lodz, fascinated
with the bustle of life, which is the photographer's stock
in trade.
The
next morning back in Warsaw I was privileged to be received
by Ambassador Victor Ashe. Amb. Ashe served for sixteen years
as the Mayor of Knoxville, Tennessee, receiving the Distinguished
Public Service Award of the U.S. Conference of Mayors prior
to his appointment to be ambassador to Poland in 2004. His
southern accent and sense of hospitality bring a welcome feeling
of country charm which, in contrast to the pictures of himself
with world leaders adorning the walls of his offices, seems
highly appropriate to an American ambassador. Small world:
it turns out that in his capacity as Mayor he officiated at
the wedding of good friends of mine back in Knoxville many
years ago.
There
are few art exhibitions that I'd travel to another state to
see, but Warsaw's CSW Zamek Ujazdowski had one installed at
the time of my visit. It was Henry Darger's "Disasters
of War" exhibit. Patrick and Iza realized my penchant
for outsider art, and arranged for me to have lunch with curator
Pawel Polit at the museum's restaurant high on a bluff overlooking
a three hundred yard reflecting pond (frozen over for my visit)
and the Vistula River beyond. Indeed, the imagery created
by self-taught artists such as Darger has long influenced
my ideas and taste in art, including my own work. Briefly
put, this art is unaffected by academia, the artist working
in absentia from the art world and market to produce
works that are raw and pure in spirit. And it doesn't get
any better than Darger; so politically incorrect that many
museums would shy away from bringing this work to the public,
but it is as equally a significant contribution.
Afterwards
Iza took me Warsaw's premier gallery, Zacheta, to see Fucien
Rops and William Degouve de Nuncques exquisite works characterized
together as "The Struggle Between Carnival and Lent."
And then it was a walk through the snow-covered park, its
evening lights creating a fairy-tale effect as they illuminated
the misty space, to the National Ethnography Museum. After
a curator's tour of Polish folk art, including ceremonial
costumes that seeing was like turning the pages of a storybook
as I went from one to the next, I presented the Highwaymen
to another highly receptive audience. There I discovered Poland's
premiere contemporary self-taught artist, Nikifor (1895-1968).
Illiterate and with a speech impediment, Nikifor found refuge
in painting images of his country that perhaps countered his
own alienation from these surroundings. He resorted to begging
when he couldn't sell his watercolors, and he may have produced
more than 10,000 of them on scrap paper.
We
toured the Poster Museum Thursday morning, and, as usual,
getting there was half the fun. The museum is located in Wilanow
Park, which was covered in snow that continued falling gently.
In a few minutes Iza relates to me centuries of the history
made there. Once again, a depth of culture that is overwhelming
to the first-time visitor is a fact of life to the initiated
Pole. Inside, the museum is sedate because of its out-of-place
austere sixties-architecture, but the exhibit of hundreds
of new calendars from around the world offered a non-stop
adventure in looking. I was moved again by the myriad offerings
of Poland's museums. It occurred to me that I was seeing more
art here than I might see at home.
Iza
took me to lunch at the Jazz Cafe another staple of Warsaw
life that would have been inconceivable Western decadence
fifteen years ago, and then to the Embassy for my afternoon
presentation at their monthly American Thursday program. Once
again, both the Embassy community and their guests from outside
were taken by this quintessential American tale. There was
one African American gentleman in the audience, one of the
Embassy officers. I worried how he would react to hearing
this White man tell the story of his people. But
he paid me the supreme compliment by simply thanking me for
writing this unique story of one of his people's triumphs
and helping to spread the word even in far-off Poland.
Then
I was off to magical Krakow, its thousand years of history
punctuated through the centuries by a regular stream of attacking
hoards, but not devastated by the Nazi and Soviet invasions
the way Warsaw and Lodz were. In fact, at least 80% of Warsaw
was leveled during WWII, but the city was reconstructed to
look as it had hundreds of years before the devastation. Maria
Brzostek, Public Affairs Specialist at the American Consulate
in Krakow, met me at the train station, and continued the
remarkable hospitality that I had been shown since landing
in Poland. She took me to the Hotel Senackicentrally located
in old town. Although well into middle age, I remain very
fond of my younger days when I stayed in a-few-dollars-a-night
hotels in third-world countries. But I wouldn't trade this
place for the world. I will never forget my view out the window
from my room: lying in bed, the window, with its gauze-like
drape, perfectly framed the top of the church of Sts. Peter
and Paul across the street, enshrouded in misty snow-light.
Like a fairy tale.
In
the morning I was off to nearby Tarnow for a presentation
to local artists, high school students of the School of Arts,
and other persons interested in arts at the Regional Museum
located in the beautiful Tarnow Town Hall. And again, I was
struck how this small regional city, virtually unknown outside
of Poland, and not distinguished within Poland, has such a
rich history of culture that is so obvious in a casual glance
at the town's architecture. Local residents do themselves
and their town a disservice by taking this wealth of culture
for granted. Receptive as always; I count my blessings as
the Highwaymen story tells itself; Can't miss. But I'm especially
edified by the receptiveness of the youngsters attention.
Afterwards I slip away again to walk the streets, stealing
a few minutes to photograph before leaving town.
One
more presentation and two days alone now to photograph before
departing for home. Introduced by William Bellis, our Public
Affairs Officer stationed in Krakow, to an audience who seemed
more like college students from Berkley than anywhere else
and of a time when social change focused there. Massolit Bookshop
is an English-language used bookstore and cafe that attracts
young intellectuals and others interested in America and ideas.
The store seems an interesting metaphor for Poland at the
crossroads, where fifteen years after shedding communism,
new signs beckon openly.
But
what also beckons are the logos that are quintessentially
America and generic, including Nike swooshes and fast-food
restaurants. At least I didn't see any "I Love Poland"
T-shirts. Our pop culture is not overt there, yet. A feeling
in the gut says it is on its way. So, no wonder I relish the
little things I experience on this magical mystery tour: When
it was too warm in the small hotel room in Warsaw and I couldn't
locate the thermostat, the desk receptionist matter-of-factly
told me to open the window. Since heat is generated by hot
water pipes that run through the city to warm the buildings
and there are no thermostats, an open window serves to regulate
interior temperatures. Charming, and delightful.
I
was stunned and perversely amused by every car coming to a
dead stop for pedestrians. It was like I cosmic power. It
felt Skinner-istic. This power seemed, ironically, almost
ludicrous, akin to walking in a cartoon. It was Wiley Coyote
about to be trumped by Roadrunner, and I felt like the invincible
Roadrunner as I set my foot out, off from the sidewalk to
bring traffic to a halt. Most sobering though were the bullet
holes that were patched to the few old buildings in Warsaw
that somehow weren't destroyed during the war. They were not
patched with the greatest care, which added a chill, especially
at the non descript building that serves as a barracks for
the few uniformed soldiers who march from it to the adjacent
downtown park to guard the flame that commemorates the graves
of their unknown brethren.
By
this time I could find my way to a pub's basement and order
pierogi any way I wanted them. Krakow's a perfect
place for me to wander alone. But more to the point, I could
do nothing but photograph, and so I did. I explored the streets,
the old town center, churches, shops, Royal Castle, market,
trolley stations, parks, noticing with intrigue people whose
lives I could only glimpse at and wonder about. And make photographs
in response to my intuitions, the challenge being to give
form to these perceptions. Fine photographs are as difficult
to realize as they seem easy to make. Their real
finesse lies in the discovery that was felt, or sensed, at
the moment of exposure, a faint possibility that there may
be a connection. And in Poland that possibility was as plentiful
as the rapid clicking of my cameras shutter, which was as
often and as involuntary as the blinking of my eyes.
|